Menu Close

What are the disadvantages of AA?

What are the disadvantages of AA?

Among the issues identified as limiting AA’s effectiveness are the movement’s preoccupation with drinking and sobriety and lack of concern for other problems. Also, the possibility is raised that AA’s insistence that its members are but “one drink away from a drunk” can become a self-fulfilling prophecy.

Can AA cause depression?

Importantly, AA attendance was associated with reduced depression over time, even when controlling for the effects of drinking at the time depression was measured. This effect of AA on depression was present for both participants with low/minimal depression and those with moderate/severe depression.

Can you take medication in AA?

Some A.A. members must take prescribed medication for serious medical problems. However, it is generally accepted that the misuse of prescription medication and other drugs can threaten the achievement and maintenance of sobriety.

What does sober mean in AA?

Answer: It means that the once powerful mental obsession to drink has diminished greatly, or perhaps, as one recovered alcoholic expressed: “To drink is no longer in my emotional vocabulary.” What a wonderful freedom for an alcoholic!

Can AA and SS marry?

AC is rare whereas AS and AC are abnormal. Compatible genotypes for marriage are: AA marries an AA. And definitely, SS and SS must not marry since there’s absolutely no chance of escaping having a child with the sickle cell disease.

Can AA and AC marry?

They refer to the hemoglobin gene constituents on the red blood cells. AC is rare, whereas AS and AC are abnormal. The compatible genotypes for marriage are; AA marries an AA — which is the best compatible, and that way, the couple save their future children the worry about genotype compatibility.

What does the AA Big Book say about depression?

In the chapter “The Doctor’s Opinion” in the Big Book, it says, “There is the manic-depressive type, who is, perhaps, the least understood by his friends, and about whom a whole chapter could be written.” I believe I cannot have sobriety without good mental health, nor can I have good mental health while drinking.

What does the big book say about anxiety?

The Big Book of Alcoholics Anonymous tells us that we are driven by a hundred forms of fear. That it is “An evil corroding thread.” Again, not necessarily phobias, but the fear that is driven by our instinctual needs. When we act out of fear, it is commonly due to one of our three basic needs being threatened.

Are you sober if you’re on antidepressants?

So many people in recovery are simply not educated about SSRIs and they think taking antidepressants equals a relapse. Like we said, this is simply not true. SSRIs do not get you intoxicated.

What is the best antidepressant for an alcoholic?

The antidepressants nefazodone, desipramine, and imipramine were found to have the most robust effects on decreasing depressive symptoms.

Is sober and clean the same thing?

To be sober is to be clear about your thoughts, honest about your emotions, and most importantly, realistic and forthcoming about your issues and your efforts towards resolving them. Someone who is clean is off their drugs,but they can still be an abusive person with serious issues.

Is sobriety the same as abstinence?

Abstinence can be defined simply as physical free from mind-altering substances. Abstinence doesn’t address behaviors, emotions, mental health, etc. It just means that the person is free of drugs/alcohol. Sobriety includes abstinence, but also encompasses much more than just stopping drinking or abusing drugs.

Why do some people have problems with AA?

Some will give relationship advice and stir up trouble. Still more have opinions on religion, politics, finances, and on and on and on. First, the true program of AA, as it is outlined in the book, takes no stance on medication, nor any other topic just mentioned.

Are there any problems with the Alcoholics Anonymous program?

Research has found that spontaneous remission of alcoholism will occur about .05 percent of the time, so you actually have a better chance of staying sober without treatment than you do with alcoholics anonymous. Another problem with Alcoholics Anonymous is that it promotes dependence on the program.

Can a member of Alcoholics Anonymous play Doctor?

• No A.A. member should “play doctor”; all medical advice and treatment should come from a qualified physician. • Active participation in the A.A. program of recovery is a major safeguard against alcoholic relapse. • Be completely honest with your doctor and yourself about the way you take your medicine.

Can a man be in an AA meeting with a woman?

This behavior is not unique to men only. Yes, this does happen occasionally, however it also happens in the world outside of AA. For this reason, there are plenty of stag meetings where an addict can be with members of the same sex. It is advisable by many old timers in AA that the women stick with the women and the men stick with the men.